“It is so simple for you, isn’t it?” I snapped, “Brought up in this utopia of yours, ensconced in the bosom of a well-defined moral universe. You have your rules, your directions all laid out before you, easy to see, easy to follow… you have no idea what it means to not know what is right and what is wrong.”
“I don’t think it’s all as simple as that,” he shot back, “and I don’t buy this line of bullshit, either. I know you know right from wrong; it’s all through everything you’ve written, in your journals, on your web site. Or is that all a lie?”
“It is the end result of thirty-five centuries of fear, mistakes, loss, and horror. You have your moral certainty handed to you on the platter of a Judeo-Christian heritage, and you presume to judge me? I think not.”
He laughed, “Princess, I’m not even a believer…”
“No? Are you a hypocrite, then? Do you believe for an instant that this affected disbelief somehow erases a lifetime of conditioning? That it makes you a creature separated from all those about you? You asked me before what I see in you- I see a man who believes. You may have no truck with the churches built by men, but you have an intimate knowledge of the God whose laws form the bedrock of the nation you call your own. Deny it. Look me in the eyes and tell me that it is categorically not so. Do that, and perhaps I will believe you.”
He nearly shot that argument straight back at me, but then he hesitated. I could see the wheels working in him and I had to suppress my urge to smile. Instead I turned, taking my eyes from his face and looking out the window over snow-covered city streets. In our short time together he had learned how adept I was at guessing the thoughts of those whom I know. By looking away I was respecting his privacy
“I don’t believe in God,” he said, his voice firm, “but I do believe that there were great and wise men in the world, and that Jesus was one of them… This does not make me a hypocrite.”
“No,” I agreed, “it does not. But how did you come to know of Jesus? How did you come to know of the bible? Or these other great men you speak of?”
“I was taught, obviously…”
“Yes, obviously.” I turned to face him again. “I was taught nothing. What morality I learned centered on obedience and survival. Had I been in the Levant perhaps things would have been different, but mine was a world of pagan disciplines, if any at all. Try to imagine it, if you can, and then remember- that is the foundation of my beliefs. If you are going to fear me, that is the reason to fear me.”
Posted on February 18th, 2005
Filed under: The Present | 4 Comments »